“I was lost, I was scared, but
a STORY led me home again.”
“Oh, no, it didn’t.” “OH, YES, IT DID.”
(Tiddler – Julia Donaldson)
C.S.Lewis once said that “A children’s story that can only be enjoyed by children is not a good children’s story in the slightest.”
Good children’s stories, in our house, are the ones that can endure a hundred bedtime readings. They are the ones that have Chris and I grinning or laughing out loud. They are satisfying to read aloud (indeed they inspire us to make an effort, to add a little drama). And as far as picture books go – they are well illustrated. In the spirit of NI bookweek, here are some of our favourites…
We have an absolute favourite in this house though and that is Hug by Jez Alborough.
This almost wordless book is one of the Best. Books. In. The. World. Ever.
The only words in the book are “Hug”, “Bobo” and “Mummy”… mostly just “Hug”.
Except, all the “Hugs” are different because just look at little Bobo’s face! With perfect illustrations toddlers can sense the emotions and the expressions as Bobo searches for his mama for a hug. This was the book we heard both our girls “read” from the earliest age alone in their rooms… that one word “hug” uttered tentatively, searchingly, desperately and finally joyously as they followed the story. They both would drop their heads and fake cry, hands in eyes, in solidarity with the monkey at the mid point.
Hug is simple, beautifully illustrated and has room for much drama and pathos… a perfect little book!
Nurture V Nature – does Olivia love Dr Seuss because she is zany and imaginative, or is Olivia zany and imaginative because she loves Dr Seuss? Who would know? One thing’s for sure, she LOVES Dr Seuss:
As Maria Russo wrote in the New York Times “Dr Seuss, over half a century ago, made learning to read an adventure, a club children would actually want to belong to. And not least, he made reading aloud something parents too, could reliably enjoy”.
I feel like Dr Seuss is an American import we could more fully embrace over here. The rhythms! The plots! The nonsense! The characters! The art! His stories are playful, and profound. You can discuss the philosophical undercurrents once your children are sleeping or just come downstairs, grinning widely, that you got to read about Mrs McCave who had 23 sons and named them all Dave.
There are articles out there about why Dr Seuss is good for beginning readers, for mastering phonics and making kids word-conscious. That’s a bonus. We just love him for the joy. There is cause to celebrate with Dr Seuss – to celebrate our own unique selves, to celebrate others, or to celebrate by being wildly, wonderfully silly.
The Wonderful World of Dr. Seuss Box Set contains a wonderful mix of some of his best (who could choose?).
More glorious storytelling and galloping characters, near-perfect rhythm and rhyme, more wonderful illustrations. We love the amazing worlds that Julia Donaldson, and the illustrators she collaborates with, take us to.
My daughter can bring home a new-to-her Julia Donaldson book from the library and even before I have read her the clever, rhyming story, she has figured out the plot from Axel Scheffler’s illustrations. She has sensed what The Highway Rat does, his character, how he fares in the story and his ultimate fate.
My friend Sharon recently sparked a great “Julia Donaldson Fan Debate” on Facebook in which several of us (slightly crazy) parents of young children got a little over-invested in our critiques, preferences and defenses of her “work”. We each tried to pick our TOP 3. It was impossible. There was disbelief and disagreement and a lot of “Oh wait! I forgot about this one!”. There was no doubt from that conversation that Julia Donaldson meets the C.S. Lewis standard.
The books we felt most passionately about were: The Snail and the Whale, A Squash and a Squeeze, Charlie Cook’s Favourite Book, The Troll, Tiddler, Zog, Tabby McTat, Monkey Puzzle, Stick Man, The Gruffalo, Tyrannosaurus Drip and The Smartest Giant in Town. And the wonderful thing is there are many, many more.
I don’t know what it is about Roger Hargreave’s Mr Men (nostalgia? their nifty little trade-mark size? the familiar story template? the bright and bold cartoons?) but I have always loved them and I love them still. There are reasons not to – the ‘simple moral lessons’ sometimes make no sense, are sometimes harsh, or inconsistent… “It’s a brutal existence”, Charlie Brooker writes in the Guardian, “albeit a cheerfully rendered one”. But, I just like them. I like the wordiness and the repetition and all those adjectives. I like the cheerfulness of the storytelling. I like that my girls can act them out. And I like the cartoons. As Charlie Brooker also says “The way Roger Hargreaves drew a shoe is still the way a shoe looks when I picture it. Same with a house. Or a hat. Or a butcher. Or a wizard. Or a cloud.”
Honorable mentions have to go to Hairy Maclary, Mog and Dogger! What else have I missed? What are the favourites in your house for adults and children alike?